Intellectual property ip litigation has received remarkable attention lately. Further, the intellectual property owner has the right to prevent the unauthorized use or sale of the property. Further, the intellectual property owner has the right to prevent the. This intellectual capital is also vital when companies enter into mergers or seek to acquire. Intellectual property ip, a significant source of intangible value, has been felt by some to be resistant to fair valuation and more amenable to estimations of intrinsic value. The result of intellectual property rights valuation depends on the purpose of the given objects intended use, and a variety of other factors.
The valuation of intellectual property if this business were split up, i would give you the land and bricks and mortar, and i would take the brands and trade marks, and i would fare better than you. There are numerous individual reasons or motivations for conducting an intellectual property valuation or economic appraisal analysis. It presents the process as a flow chart, in which the first step is determining the purpose of the valuation i. Intellectual property is an economic driver in canada, the u. The importance of intellectual property valuation and protection. With billions of dollars at risk, the implication for expert witnesses focused on valuation. In present economy, the share of intellectual property assets in the total value of a company has greatly increased, which brings greater importance to. Valuation of intellectual property and beyond valuation overview o discounted cash flows where o cash flow is defined as proceeds minus costs o discount rate determined by risk that cash flows will not materialize due to various risk factors o comparables relief from royalties o valuation of intellectual property in established market using. Intellectual property ip valuation is an increasingly important aspect of managing assets in the currently complex and everchanging business world. Stay current on key business valuation issues related to intellectual property with indepth analysis on nearly 200 cases from bvrs legal team, plus online access to all of the full court opinions easily search valuation cases using the compendiums handy chart that organizes the cases by name, state, and date, and includes a short summary of each. It attempts to answer the question by providing a monetary value or contribution that the intellectual property provides, whether directly to the business or indirectly by increasing the value of other parts of the. International valuation standard ivs 210 provides general guidance on the valuation of intangible assets including intellectual property does not distinguish between different purposes of the valuation, i.
Used twice annually since 1999, this edition will be used in 3semesterhour courses in 2012. Introduction intellectual property ip can be sold, mortgaged, or disposed of like any ordinary property. This report refers to the valuation of intellectual property ip and intellectual property. Tax implications of the intellectual property valuation. What is a piece of intellectual property, and what is an intangible asset. Used twice annually since 1999, this edition will be used in 3semesterhour courses. Intellectual property rights stellenbosch university. Welldesigned intellectual property rights systems also encourage innovators to disclose their knowledge so that future innovators can build on it, thereby helping to accelerate the rate of innovation. Fundamentals of intellectual property valuation answers some of the most frequently asked questions about ip and valuation, including. For example, while fair market value is appropriate for most tax valuations, many different standards of value may be estimated for the intellectual property. Protecting your intellectual property from competitors gressmedia. Valuation checklist the following ipr valuation checklist sets out some of the factors you need to take. Reilly is a managing director of willamette management associates.
Students handbook valuation of intellectual property. The most noticeable difference between intellectual property and. Review of ip valuation approaches, methods and standards. Ip assets are a subset of intangible assets and distinguished from other intangible assets by the fact that these are created by. Monetary or financial valuation is the process of determining or. When are they the same and when are they different. Intellectual property is a general term for the set of intangible assets owned and legally protected by a company from outside use or implementation without consent. Intellectual property valuation there are different methods for valuing ip and any ip valuation will vary depending on a broad range of factors, primarily the time, context or purpose and application of the valuation.
Determining the value of your intellectual property heer law. The fundamentals of intellectual property for the entrepreneur. Valuation of intellectual property module 4 the valuation of intellectual property if this business were split up, i would give you the land and bricks and mortar, and i would take the brands and trade marks, and i would fare better than you. Intellectual property is becoming an essential asset for corporations to achieve market dominance and maintain profitability as they continue into the future. O valuation of intellectual property in established market using royalty rates for similar products o used to assess damages in infringement cases o welldeveloped case law but requires established market o market o assumes willing buyer and willing seller in armslength transaction and sufficient exposure. Valuation of intellectual property rights is part of the good management of intellectual property within an organisation. This is approximately the 24th revision of a conventional 472 pp. He is a certified public accountant, accredited in business valuation. Anson, weston, fundamentals of intellectual property valuation. Estimations are performed on the basis of the costs that would be spent to obtain an equivalent ip asset with similar use or function. We believe in providing professional, competent and thorough analysis that is specific to the clients needs on each and every intellectual property valuation project. The correct valuation of the intellectual property right at stake is therefore essential to guarantee a fair recovery of the damages. The role of intellectual property ip as an important value determinant is widely recognized. Intellectual property valuation, valuation of ip asset assessment.
The course covers the fundamentals of intellectual property, with a major emphasis on intellectual property strategies. However, unlike tangible properties, the determination of the vaue of ip has l been a challenge. He has advised clients in valuation matters for over 40 years. When experts are seeking an intellectual property valuation tool they can use.
To determine the value of a specific instance of intellectual property such as a trademark, patent or, our professionals rigorously apply appropriate. An overview of intellectual property and intangible asset. The value of intellectual property, intangible assets and goodwill 15. Although there are generally accepted components of the valuation process, each intellectual property valuation has unique elements.
Overview of issues accompanying the growth of the knowledge sector in many economies is an increased interest in property rights for the knowledge being created by firms and individuals, that is, in the protection of those rights via intellectual property. Some assets are easier to value than others, and some valuations are more precise than others. A valuation is prepared, for example, for transactions, pricing and strategic purposes, financing securitization and collateralization, tax planning and compliance, and litigation support factors driving the value of intellectual property. Aug 17, 2015 for example, intellectual property is an asset, and as such it can be bought, sold, licensed, exchanged, or gratuitously given away like any other form of property. An overview of intellectual property and intangible asset valuation models jeffrey h. Valuation and dealmaking of technologybased intellectual. The basic forms of intellectual property protection are patents, trade secrets, trademarks, trade dress, and s. Valuing technology based intellectual property an innovation catalyst seminar prepared and presented by marcus tarrant managing director mission hq pty. Intellectual property rights change in value for a variety of reasons. It is intended as a reference for apec economies primarily to enable them to present to stakeholders why ip has value, how it is being valued, and why it is important to come up with an ip valuation mechanism.
Pdf intellectual property and the valuation of biotechnology. Jan 29, 2020 intellectual property can account for over 40% of the average business and is often not reflected on their balance sheet. Oecd report on patents and economic performance 17. This manual is a result of two threeday workshops on promoting innovation through a mechanism for ip valuation, financing and leveraging ip assets held in manila, philippines in 2017. A valuation process for intellectual property in a. In this article the main valuation methods for ip described in.
This intellectual capital ic reporting approach uses the same fundamentals of classical accounting. A simple example will serve to illustrate the difference between intrinsic value and fair market value as outlined herein. Final report from the expert group on intellectual property. Apart from the fact that these objects can be used for commercial purposes, intellectual property valuation allows one to put the objects on a balance sheet as an intangible asset, allowing the. Newer asset valuation methods can also be used to determine the value of intellectual property while it is still in the development stage.
Intellectual property ip can be sold, mortgaged, or disposed of like any ordinary property. There are many kinds of and for every kind and stage of its ip. For example, intellectual property is an asset, and as such it can be bought, sold, licensed, exchanged, or gratuitously given away like any other form of property. This post outlines the three accepted valuation approaches and comments on their application in measuring ip. But intellectual property is quite different from most tangible assets. Valuation of intellectual property and beyond valuation of. Fair market value with a fair market value standard, it is assumed that a hypothetical transaction takes. Journal of intellectual property rights 2007 and 2009 16. Valuation of intellectual property and beyond valuation.
In an era where intellectual property ip transactions account. Valuing intellectual property issues for mergers and acquisitions the article appears in the 2005 indiana continuing legal education forum iclef business valuations and preparations for sale seminar proceedings. Because of the vexatious nature of valuing intellectual property, the models used for. Intellectual property will gradually become the criteria and milestone of a companys prospective performance and. Valuation of intellectual property as part of the assetbased approach. The guiding term here is reasonable knowledge of all relevant facts. Though there are several generally accepted ways to measure the value of ip. Intellectual property valuation business queensland. Each form of protection confers a different type of property right, and each operates differently, as summarized below. Intellectual property ip valuation is part science, part art. In present economy, the share of intellectual property assets in the total value of a company has greatly increased, which brings greater importance to a correct evaluation. Intellectual property valuations pellegrino associates. Show full abstract intellectual property valuation methods have been videly discussed in several works.
It enables owners to design coherent strategies and it underpins the purpose of intellectual property. An output of the human mind may be attributed with intellectual property rights. Intellectual property valuation methods consor consor. Overview of issues accompanying the growth of the knowledge sector in many economies is an increased interest in property rights for the knowledge being created by firms and individuals, that is, in the protection of those rights via intellectual property rights ipr. The art is in how the ip valuation analysts apply these formulas to. There are different methods for valuing ip and any ip valuation will vary depending on a broad range of factors, primarily the time, context or purpose and application of the valuation. This is a subject that is difficult to find quality information outside of a law firm or ip company. Oct 17, 2019 quantitative valuation relies on measurable data or numerical information to produce an estimate of the value of your assets. Valuation and metrics based quality assessment of ip. Final report from the expert group on intellectual. The economic role of intellectual property valuation and identifying the current approaches and methodologies in this regard which determines the price of products and intellectual property services in a quantitative form leads to a boost in technological productions and development. Apr 24, 2018 essentially, intellectual property assets can increase revenue or reduce business costs, and when they generate an income for the business being sold, a number of valuation methods can be utilized. These are like any other property, and the law allows the owner to use the same to economically profit from the intellectual work. The brooks kushman intellectual property primer can help you spot intellectual property issues, preserve and protect your rights, avoid potential liability, and effectively enforce your intellectual property rights.
Due to this special character of ip, problems arise in the appraisal process and not every valuation approach is appropriate for the valuation of ip in the same way. This article tries to quantify the role of ip in companies valuation by comparing a sample of. Fact sheet intellectual property valuation iprhelpdesk. Topics include forms of intellectual property, ip strategy, ip markets, startups, negotiations involving ip, ip due diligence, and technology transfer, licensing and commercialization, valuation and metrics based quality.
Although many valuation definitions exist, most formal intellectual property valuation reports will likely refer to the fair market value standard. Dec 12, 2014 valuing your intellectual property like other forms of property, you can buy, sell and license ip, it is important you understand the value your trade mark, patent or design. The value of an asset is the value of the future economic benefits it brings. Intangible asset valuation in general, and intellectual property valuation in particular, are specialized processes derived from financial and economic valuation concepts. Valuation of intellectual property rights is incredibly important. Valuation of the intellectual property to be used as security for bank loans or to attract venture capital and investors is essential. Realistic valuations of intellectual property methods and techniques.
A patent provides an owner with the right to exclude others from. Indeed, knowing the economic value and importance of the intellectual property rights you create and develop assists. The methods described are routinely used in licensing, transfer pricing and ordinary valuation, as well as in the course of patent infringement litigation. A 2010 study entitled intellectual property valuation. This paper first describes the three basic valuation methods cost, market and incomeand the current valuation methods for intellectual property 25 percent rule, industry standards, ranking.
As intellectual property ip and intellectual property rights iprs play an increasingly important role in corporate strategy, the accurate valuation of ip remains a major obstacle to their emergence as a tradable asset class. Understanding that intellectual property valuation is effective in management resources, and that results of such valuation is used in the process of decisionmaking, signifies intellectual property valuation even more. It is important to note that print sources are often better than electronic ones for getting a sense of a specific area of law. An efficient and equitable intellectual property system can help all countries realize intellectual property s potential as a powerful tool for economic development and social and cultural wellbeing. Determining the valuation of intellectual property is often complicated due to the fact that the property is considered an intangible asset. His assignments have included appraisals of nearly every type of tangible and intangible property as well as consultations relative to royalty rates, economic life, and litigation damages for intellectual property. Any information that provides economic value that is not in the. Valuing your intellectual property better business finance. Ip valuation analysts, regardless of which school they hail from, learn the same formulas.
It highlights the key strengths and weaknesses of these models. Headlines and the notion of billiondollar damage awards have captured the imagination of patent owners and potential defendants alike. A great primer for anyone needing to understand the fundamentals of intellectual property valuation. Intellectual property valuation european commission.
The intellectual property valuation process represents a systematic framework for the analyst to answer a specifrobert f. In doing international intellectual property research, one will often see terms such as neighboring. This book gives you that information to help you make an informed negotiation. The valuation analyst establishes the value of the intellectual property owners overall business enterprise value as a result of owning the intellectual property and then compares that to the business enterprise value if the owner did not, in fact, have or control the intellectual property or was not able to use it in its business enterprise. The science is in the financial formulas that ip valuation analysts use to quantify the myriad of inputs that drive value. Stemming from its ability to provide a firm with competitive advantages, defining ip as an asset aims to provide it the same protective rights as physical property. This working paper summarises the state of the art in patent valuation methods. The value of an asset, whether tangible or intangible, can be estimated.
890 282 1228 678 1167 1617 1557 231 1104 1166 109 273 1316 129 1390 1471 1496 865 1522 156 1228 155 1091 1193 232 1420 188 519 375 1338 358 549 1228 1282 1212 1174 958 272 220